Foreign pension plans are one of the most misunderstood reporting areas for US persons living or working abroad. The central question is not simply whether a plan is called a "pension" - it is whether the plan has an individual savings or investment component. If it does, it is almost certainly reportable. If it is a purely governmental defined benefit plan where the individual holds no specific account and exercises no investment control, reporting may not be required.
The Core Distinction
Purely governmental defined benefit pension: The government promises a fixed payment based on years of service. The employee has no individual account, no investment choices, and no access to the funds before retirement. Examples: US Social Security, basic state pension systems. Generally not reportable on FBAR or Form 8938.
Plan with individual savings component: The employee has an account balance they can track, investment options they can choose, or voluntary contributions they make. Examples: Israeli Keren Hishtalmut, Canadian RRSP, German Riester-Rente, UK Self-Invested Personal Pension (SIPP), Russian NPS individual pension accounts. Generally reportable on FBAR and Form 8938.
FBAR Reporting - Does the Pension Qualify?
FinCEN Form 114 (FBAR) must be filed for any foreign financial account with aggregate value exceeding $10,000 at any point during the year. The question is whether a foreign pension constitutes a "financial account" at a foreign financial institution.
Does the pension plan maintain an individual account balance in the employee's name?
→
YES → Likely reportable on FBAR
Does the employee have the ability to direct investments within the plan?
→
YES → Likely reportable on FBAR
Can the employee make voluntary contributions beyond mandatory amounts?
→
YES → Likely reportable on FBAR
Is this a purely governmental promise of a future fixed benefit with no individual account?
→
Potentially NOT reportable - fact-specific analysis required
Does the plan hold assets at a foreign financial institution?
→
YES → Check FinCEN guidance; may require FBAR even for government plans
Summary - Reporting Requirements by Plan Type
| Plan Type | FBAR Required? | Form 8938? | Form 3520? | Notes |
|---|
| Individual savings / investment account (employer + employee contributions) | Yes | Yes | Possibly | Most employer-sponsored plans with individual accounts. Report FMV of account. |
| Purely governmental DB pension (no individual account) | Generally No | Generally No | No | Basic state pensions, social security equivalents. Confirm structure. |
| Government plan that holds assets at a financial institution | Fact-Specific | Fact-Specific | No | FinCEN has not provided definitive guidance on all cases. |
| Foreign trust-based pension plan | Yes | Yes | Possibly | Foreign pension trusts may require Form 3520 as foreign trust with US beneficiary. IRC §402(b). |
| Foreign annuity (no cash surrender value) | No | No | No | Pure annuity contracts without cash value are not financial accounts. |
| Foreign life insurance with cash value (savings component) | Yes | Yes | No | Cash surrender value of policy is reportable. 31 CFR §1010.350(c). |
Distributions from Foreign Pensions
When a US person receives distributions from a foreign pension, the US tax treatment depends on treaty provisions and the nature of the plan. Without a treaty, foreign pension distributions are generally fully taxable as ordinary income under IRC §402(b) - the US does not recognize the tax-deferred status of foreign plans that were never approved as US qualified plans.
With a treaty, the treaty article covering pensions typically provides that pension income is taxable only in the country of residence (the US, once the individual is a US resident) or in the source country, depending on the specific treaty language. The analysis is treaty-specific and cannot be generalized.
Country-Specific Analysis
FBAR: Required. RRSP and RRIF are individual accounts held at Canadian financial institutions.
Form 8938: Required. Report fair market value.
Tax treatment: Under Article XVIII(7) of the US-Canada Treaty, a US resident who is a Canadian RRSP/RRIF holder may elect to defer US tax on income accruing in the plan. The election must be made on the first US tax return on which the plan must be reported. This election is frequently missed by taxpayers and their preparers. Once missed, it cannot easily be made retroactively. If the election was not made, accrued income in the RRSP is currently taxable in the US.
Form 3520: Generally not required under current IRS guidance (Rev. Proc. 2020-17 provides relief).
FBAR: Required for SIPPs and defined contribution workplace pensions. Defined benefit "promise" pensions - fact-specific.
Form 8938: Required.
Tax treatment: Under Article 17 of the US-UK Treaty, pension income paid to a US resident is generally taxable only in the US. However, lump-sum distributions may be taxable in both countries. The 25% UK tax-free lump sum is not recognized as tax-free by the US - the full lump sum is taxable in the US absent a specific treaty position.
Form 3520: May be required if the pension is structured as a trust. Rev. Proc. 2020-17 provides relief for certain UK pensions meeting specific requirements.
FBAR: Required. Keren Hishtalmut (continuing education fund) and Kupat Gemel (pension savings fund) are individual savings vehicles.
Form 8938: Required.
Tax treatment: The US-Israel Treaty does not provide the same deferral mechanisms as the US-Canada Treaty. Employer contributions to Keren Hishtalmut may be taxable as income in the US in the year contributed. Investment growth within the plan may be currently taxable in the US. This is an area of active practitioner disagreement and the IRS has not issued definitive guidance. Consult a specialist.
Form 3520: May be required if the fund is structured as a trust with US beneficiaries.
FBAR: Required for individual Riester-Rente accounts and defined contribution occupational pension (bAV) accounts.
Form 8938: Required.
Tax treatment: Under Article 18 of the US-Germany Treaty, pensions paid from Germany to a US resident are taxable in the US. The German tax-deferred treatment during accumulation is not recognized by the US. Employer contributions to bAV plans may be partially excludable from US income under treaty provisions, but the analysis is complex.
PFIC risk: If the pension invests in foreign mutual funds, PFIC issues may arise.
FBAR: Required for individual NPF accounts.
Form 8938: Required.
Tax treatment: The US-Russia Tax Treaty was suspended by Russia effective August 8, 2023. As of 2026, no treaty benefits are available for residents of Russia. Distributions from Russian pension funds are fully taxable in the US as ordinary income. The Russian mandatory pension system (OPS) individual accumulation accounts are reportable on FBAR and Form 8938. The basic state guaranteed pension component - which is a promise based on points, not an individual account - may not require FBAR reporting, but this is fact-specific.
Practical issue: Accessing funds from Russian pension accounts as a US person may be complicated by sanctions compliance requirements.
Rev. Proc. 2020-17: The IRS provided relief from Form 3520 filing for certain Canadian (RRSP, RRIF), UK, and other qualifying foreign retirement plans. This relief applies if the plan meets the definition of a "tax-favored foreign retirement trust" or "tax-favored foreign non-retirement savings trust" as defined in the revenue procedure. Even with this relief, FBAR and Form 8938 reporting are still required.
Authority: 31 USC §5314; 31 CFR §1010.350; IRC §6038D; Form 8938 instructions; IRC §402(b) (foreign plan distributions); IRC §679 (foreign trusts); Form 3520; Form 3520-A; Rev. Proc. 2020-17 (foreign retirement plan relief); US-Canada Tax Treaty Art. XVIII; US-UK Tax Treaty Art. 17; US-Israel Tax Treaty Art. 20; US-Germany Tax Treaty Art. 18; FinCEN Form 114 instructions; IRS Notice 2023-55 (US-Russia treaty suspension).